(314) 669-4473
attract top insurance talent

Building a successful insurance team takes more than just finding the right person for the job. Recruiting competent, qualified talent requires research and preparation, and hiring managers and executives must be savvy to find the best candidates in the industry.

1. Engage in Targeted Recruiting

Targeted recruiting is an effective way to attract top insurance talent. One approach is to identify the places where your ideal candidate is likely to be found. For instance, building relationships with engineering colleges that specialize in insurance-related fields or searching job boards specific to your industry can help you locate experienced professionals.

2. Develop an Effective Compensation Plan

An effective compensation plan can be a key tool in attracting and retaining top talent. A good plan should take into account the importance of certification, experience, and job performance to ensure potential candidates view your company as a viable option for fair remuneration for their work. Statistics show that compensation is a major factor in the recruitment and retention of employees. According to a study conducted by Glassdoor, 67% of job seekers said that salary and compensation were critical when considering job offers.

3. Offer Flexible Schedules and Benefits

Offering flexible scheduling options, such as work-from-home opportunities, flexible hours, and vacation days can help attract top talent in the insurance industry. Additionally, offering health insurance, retirement plans, and other perks can go a long way in convincing talented individuals to join your team. According to a survey by the Society for Human Resource Management, offering flexible scheduling options was the third most important benefit to employees after health care and retirement plans.

4. Invest in Professional Development Training Opportunities

Offering unique educational and development programs for employees in the insurance industry can help retain top talent. This can include opportunities to obtain professional certifications or licenses, as well as continuing education courses tailored to their field. Professional development training contributes to an attractive working environment that sets you apart and shows your commitment to the ongoing education of your staff.

5. Leverage Social Media to Share Your Job Openings

Social media can be an effective platform to share job openings and attract qualified talent from the insurance industry. LinkedIn is a popular platform for recruiters and job seekers, with over 700 million users globally. Posting job listings on Twitter and Facebook can also help expand your reach and attract potential candidates. A report by LinkedIn found that social media is an effective tool for recruiting and hiring, with 73% of job seekers using social media to research companies before applying.

6. Importance of Diversity and Inclusion in Hiring Practices

Creating a diverse and inclusive work environment is important for attracting and retaining top talent. A study by McKinsey & Company found that diverse companies are more likely to outperform their non-diverse counterparts by 35%. When hiring, it’s important to be intentional about promoting diversity and inclusion in your hiring practices. This includes actively seeking out candidates from underrepresented backgrounds, implementing unbiased hiring practices, and providing training on diversity and inclusion to employees.

7. Employee Engagement and Retention Strategies

Creating a positive work environment and building a strong company culture is essential for retaining top talent. Employee engagement and retention strategies can include offering employee recognition programs, promoting open communication, providing opportunities for career growth and development, and fostering a supportive work environment. A study by Gallup found that employees who are engaged in their work are more likely to remain with their current employer and perform at a higher level.

Last Words: Retaining Top Insurance Talent Requires Consistent Strategies

Effective recruitment and retention strategies for the insurance industry require a combination of targeted recruiting, an effective compensation plan, flexible schedules and benefits, social media outreach, and professional development opportunities. By promoting diversity and inclusion in hiring practices and creating a positive work environment that fosters employee engagement and retention, insurance companies can attract and retain top talent in the industry.

Here's What Makes Us Different

Please let us know if you have any questions

30+ Years Recruiting Experience

Rich Network of Contacts and Valuable Resources.

Flexible Payment Options

Customized Plans Suited for Your Business Model.

Insurance Industry Focus

Deep Understanding Of Company Culture and Needs.

Custom Hands-on Approach

With Our TeamUP™ 3-Step Process Everyone Wins.

Trusted Hiring Partner

We Place Vetted, Qualified, Culture-Ready People.

Two Written Guarantees

100% No-Poach Guarantee
1-Year Replacement Guarantee.*

*dependent on assignment

Transform your insurance agency from failing to flourishing with our proven recruiting services.


Say goodbye to the headaches of sorting through resumes and waiting on no-show candidates. Let us find and retain top talent for your business so you can focus on growth and success. With our help, you’ll experience the benefits of skilled and dedicated employees who seamlessly fit into your company culture. Start your journey to a thriving insurance agency today.